Nicholas (nwhyte) wrote,
Nicholas
nwhyte

October Books 1) Divided Loyalties, by Gary Russell

Dear lord, it's 25 October and I have not blogged a single book so far this month - and I have finished 11 so far, though four of those are Clarke submissions which won't be recorded here except by Greek letter.

Anyway, to this novel, which is actually the only original Who novel to feature the Celestial Toymaker (The Nightmare Fair is based on an unmade TV story), along with the Fifth Doctor, Adric, Nyssa and Tegan. I see from online commentary that the book is generally hated by fans; I am really rather puzzled by this. Perhaps this is the effect of reading it in 2014, when we have had a number of Fifth Doctor audios reuniting Tegan and Nyssa (and Turlough rather than Adric), and the Doctor's relationship with Gallifrey has been remoulded rather substantially; what was described as fanwank in 1999 seems if anything rather forward-looking now.

Anyway. Each of the four main characters is forced, as part o the Toymaker's games, to relive elements of their past lives, which I thought were extrapolated rather well given that we saw bits of Adric and Nyssa's home planets on TV and live on Tegan's. The most entertaining bit for me, especially knowing now that I am re-reading Lungbarrow next month, was the idea of the young Doctor hanging around with nine friends on Gallifrey, including basically almost all the renegade Time Lords we had ever heard of and a couple more; I found it a neat effort to explain and make consistent our hero's observed relationships with, for instance, the Monk and Drax, not to mention the Master.

It was still a bit rambling in places, so it won't get top marks for me, but I'm genuinely surprised by the vitriol this drew from fandom on first publication. It seems to me rather unfair on Gary Russell, whose record has many more hits than misses.
Tags: bookblog 2014, doctor who, doctor who: 05, writer: gary russell
Subscribe

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 3 comments