Nicholas (nwhyte) wrote,
Nicholas
nwhyte

BSFA short stories: my ballot

Long plane flights and short stories often work quite well in combination for me, and I used the last week's travels, among other things, to read through the BSFA shortlist. I should say that I ranked my choices before then turning to Martin Lewis's discussion, which illustrates the point that chacun a son goût.

5) Afterbirth, by Kameron Hurley

Martin Lewis asks if this would work for someone who hasn't read God's War buy the same author. I can only say that it didn't really work for me; I didn't quite get either the background to the story or why I was supposed to care about it. Important themes, good writing, but didn't really engage me. The only story of the five that I would rank below "No Award" (if the BSFA had that category, which it doesn't.)

4) The Silver Wind, by Nina Allen

A piece with rather interesting scenery, juxtaposing two alternative present-day Londons linked by a mysterious dwarf watchmaker. Lots of intriguing details which however didn't quite go anywhere.

3) The Copenhagen Interpretation, by Paul Cornell

A fantasy steampunk short in the same world as the same author's Hugo-nominated "One Of Our Bastards is Missing"; I enjoyed the pace and appreciated the basic concept, would have liked a bit more story, but decent enough.

2) Covehithe, by China Miéville

Originally published in the Guardian, of all places. Basically a very short piece about living, walking oil rigs. As usual with Miéville, gorgeous prose.

1) Of Dawn, by Al Robertson

Martin Lewis (and his commenters) complain that this story is variously too much like other recent British sf or too much engaged with its own internal references. I obviously haven't read enough recent British sf to get jaded with this kind of thing because I enjoyed it a lot; I thought the depiction of the central character's grief very true to life, and the layered delving into a personal and geographical past fitted the central premise in a way I found very satisfying. I would agree that it is perhaps a shade too long, but will put it top of my ballot anyway.
Tags: bsfa 2011, writer: china mieville, writer: paul cornell
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment