?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Doctor Who Rewatch: 25

Once again I'm behind with writing these up, mainly because I found some of these stories rather difficult to watch or to care about writing them up once I had watched them. But things had got better by the end.

I started watching the Trial of a Time Lord season in a rather foul mood. But in fact, rather to my surprise, I found myself warming to The Mysterious Planet - in relative terms, of course; it's definitely in the lower third of Robert Holmes' stories, and has a number of plot elements recycled from his previous scripts when he did them better. But there is a sense that the show might be finding its feet again: back to the 25-minute format, and also embedding the season in a narrative arc (which was successful last time it was tried) in which Time Lords up to no good; the basics are actually there, and I think it is the production values that let it down as much as anything. (Though I should admit that the plot is also a bit confusing and over-filled.) The Mysterious Planet is a little dull but it's not actively bad, unlike most of the previous season.

I hold the unfashionable view that Mindwarp is much the best Sixth Doctor story. Unlike The Mysterious Planet, it is perhaps a little padded rather than crammed, but the performances make up for it - particularly Nabil Shaban and Chris Ryan, with Brian Blessed doing some excellent shouting. Also the framing narrative comes into its own here, with the Doctor as puzzled as we viewers are in some cases.

I was able to forgive many of the flaws of Earthshock because of the killing off of Adric. The destruction of Peri's brain is a great shock moment which lifts Mindwarp from merely being good to being classic. We are building up to something shocking throughout the story, and it actually delivers; dramatically, this is not just the high point of the season, it's the high point of the Colin Baker era.

So farewell to poor Peri. Having been listening to her excellent extended adventures courtesy of Big Finish over the last few years (where Nicola Bryant has now started directing stories as well as appearing in them), it's rather a shock to return to how poorly she was served in the original scripts. The Peri/Six dynamic never comes quite right, and she bears all the hallmarks of being trapped in an abusive bullying relationship. Nicola Bryant is very pleasant to watch, but the same cannot be said for what is done to her character. (Apart, as stated above, from her dramatic demise. Up until the start of this year, my personal fanon was that Peri actually does die, and the story with King Hyrcanos is made up to make the Doctor feel better; but Big Finish's Peri and the Piscon Paradox has persuaded me that there is more than one satisfactory way to answer that question.)

Apart from the Vervoids themselves, Terror of the Vervoids isn't all that bad. There are good guest appearances (Honor Blackman being the most remarkable), Mel is a welcome change of tone if somewhat abruptly added to the show, and the plot is a decent claustrophobia / paranoia / base under siege combination. The Vervoids are unfortunately dull, obviously zipped into their suits and not very plant-like, but again they are not the worst of the monsters of Who. Where the story goes off the rails is the framing narrative, where it simply becomes confusing as to how the Doctor has access to future adventures, why he should be on trial now for something he hasn't done yet, and why we should be particularly outraged if the Matrix has been hacked.

And then The Ultimate Foe is a poor farewell to a misused Doctor. There is little good to be said of it - Eric Saward's original script for the second episode makes more sense than Pip and Jane Baker's version as broadcast, but that is not saying much. The Valeyard's role does become clear, and actually interesting, but the back-story of Time Lord politics simply becomes confusing and the means and motivation of the Master, crucial to what passes for a plot, are even less comprehensible than usual. (And we have the cop-out of Peri's faked death, which kills the drama of the only interesting development of the entire season.)

When I started this rewatch, Colin Baker was firmly at the bottom of my list of favourite Doctors; I'm afraid he is still there, at least as far as his TV performance goes. The character is simply an unattractive one, and Baker is not able to invest him with sufficient heroism to overcome this (cf Pertwee, who for similar reasons is second last in my ranking, but was able to turn on the charm a bit more often). It's far from being all Baker's fault; the decision to have him assault Peri in his very first episode is a disastrous one which taints that story and most subsequent ones for me; the bizarre way in which the camera habitually zooms in on him pulling a funny face as the closing music rolls becomes very tedious very fast; and even what we thought we knew about the Doctor's background in Time Lord continuity is undermined for no terribly good reason (I think Six has proportionally more stories with fellow time lords than any other Doctor, including One and Four who actually had Gallifreyan companions). Part of this is the mis-writing of the Peri/Doctor dynamic, but then things actually deteriorate in terms of production values and coherence once she has been killed off.

Having said that, Baker does rather well in the Big Finish audios - it's a cliche, I know, but I do recommend Peri and the Piscon Paradox, Bloodtide, The Doomwood Curse, Brotherhood of the Daleks, Paper Cuts, Jubilee, and The Wormery. I also recommend, if you can find it, Colin Baker's continuation of Peri's story, The Age of Chaos.

And suddenly we have a new Doctor, as well as a new companion. Time and the Rani is widely excoriated as the worst of the Seventh Doctor era (coming bottom of the poll I ran a few years back and third last in the DWM Mighty 200 poll) but I don't quite see that (granted, I have a couple of other heterodox views on this period of the programme). It's a bit unexciting - the Rani's evil plan consists more of exposition than action, and the Tetraps are not well executed - but at least one can understand what is going on, and most of the cast seem to want to do it well.

And McCoy's Doctor is rather a breath of fresh air - once again I find I am watching the show because I want to see what he will do or say next, a feeling I haven't really had since Tom Baker's departure. I still don't think that Time and the Rani is terribly good, but it seems to me unfarily underrated.

And suddenly we seem to have a complete step change with Paradise Towers, a glorious story which merges comedy and horror - Richard Briers dressed up as a Hitler-like bureaucrat; girl gangs with extraordinary slogans; cannibalistic little old ladies; a hero who isn't terribly heroic; an evil architect and a swimming pool. I don't know what it is, but there is a sudden injection of energy and confidence into the show at this point that, in my view, lasts for most of the rest of Old Who's run. The Doctor may not have much of a clue as to what is going on, but we are urging him to work it out and we get there at much the same time as he does. My daily watching of the old episodes has become a pleasure again, rather than a chore.

So, farewell to Six, but ending on a more optimistic note than I have done for a while. Also feeling slightly elegiac in that I know there will be only two more of these posts.

< An Unearthly Child - The Aztecs | The Sensorites - The Romans | The Web Planet - Galaxy 4 | Mission To The Unknown - The Gunfighters | The Savages - The Highlanders | The Underwater Menace - Tomb of the Cybermen | The Abominable Snowmen - The Wheel In Space | The Dominators - The Space Pirates | The War Games - Terror of the Autons | The Mind of Evil - The Curse of Peladon | The Sea Devils - Frontier in Space | Planet of the Daleks - The Monster of Peladon | Planet of the Spiders - Revenge of the Cybermen | Terror of the Zygons - The Seeds of Doom | The Masque of Mandragora - The Talons of Weng-Chiang | Horror of Fang Rock - The Invasion of Time | The Ribos Operation - The Armageddon Factor | Destiny of the Daleks - Shada | The Leisure Hive - The Keeper of Traken | Logopolis - The Visitation | Black Orchid - Mawdryn Undead | Terminus - The Awakening | Frontios - Attack of the Cybermen | Vengeance on Varos - In A Fix With Sontarans | The Mysterious Planet - Paradise Towers | Delta and the Bannermen - The Greatest Show in the Galaxy | Battlefield - The TV Movie >

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
londonkds
Jul. 24th, 2011 08:36 pm (UTC)
Debate proposition: Humker and Tandrell are the unpleasant overtones of homophobia that afflicted a couple of Holmes's Blake's 7 scripts reaching Who. Y/N?

Wholly agree about Peri. My personal fandom is that the Doctor never investigated to find out if she was alive or not because if she had died both his Sixth and Seventh incarnations would have gone the full High Plains Drifter on Gallifrey.

Terror of the Vervoids fails for me because it is impossible to come up with any retrospective rational motivation for the character who turns out to be the murderer to have been so.
wwhyte
Jul. 24th, 2011 09:30 pm (UTC)
I agree that Paradise Towers is actually pretty nice. The dialogue is head and shoulders above anything we had in the Saward era (excepting Caves): short, direct sentences full of short, direct words, giving the impression of characters who are interested in the effect they're having on others rather than just liking to hear themselves talk. The concept's unoriginal and episode 4 is a bit meh but you're completely right about the energy levels kicking up a notch here.
steve_mollmann
Jul. 25th, 2011 03:49 am (UTC)
I agree with you completely about Mindwarp. Easily the best Colin Baker story.
wwhyte
Aug. 27th, 2011 03:33 am (UTC)
On Peri: I think Nicola Bryant does better with Eric Saward's awful dialogue than anyone other than Peter Davison, in terms of making it sound like what the person is thinking of saying. She had a very tough hand to play and really gave it her all.

Colin Baker, on the other hand, doesn't. He just comes off as the playground bully in geek school.
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

June 2019
S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30      

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by yoksel