Nicholas (nwhyte) wrote,
Nicholas
nwhyte

Prisoner of the Judoon

I never got around to writing up the second series of Sarah Jane Adventures properly - in summary, I loved the one where Maria and her father came back, thought the one with Sarah Jane's parents had too much cut and paste from other New Who and SJA stories, and was surprised that the Brigadier's return in the last story did not really grab me - but the third series is off to a good start. Of course it's on while I am at work during the week, but I think I will find ways (cough, cough) of catching up at the weekends.

Prisoner of the Judoon is surprisingly subversive for a children's show. The Judoon are authority figures whose authority stems as much from fear as from the Shadow Proclamation, and who behave quite unreasonably - their deference to regulation as much as their inclination for summary execution (and tendency to get deflected from it as well). Meanwhile the Androvax, while definitely a genocidal villain, is given a realistic motivation which comes close to being a sympathetic treatment. Not all policemen are your friends, children; not all bad people are irredeemable.

On the series format as a whole, we are heading in the dirction of the Clyde Langer adventures, which I think recognises Daniel Anthony's talents. Elisabeth Sladen did not sound totally at ease doing the series intro. However, she clearly had a ball being the Androvax in Sarah's body - much more exciting than being possessed by spiders, Mandragora or Eldrad. And the fun plotline in this series is obviously going to be letting Rani's parents in on the secret of alien activity and their daughter's involvement in it.
Tags: doctor who: sarah jane
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments