?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

The Three Doctors, reconsidered

When I first rewatched The Three Doctors a couple of years ago, my assessment of it was pretty harsh, but I gave it another go this last week and saw more merit in it this time. Back in October 2006 it was only the fourth Pertwee story I had watched, and I had not got very far into the Troughton era either, so my basis of comparison was not very broad; taken in consideration of the surrounding stories (especially the immediately preceding, overrated Season 9), The Three Doctors is not bad at all. (Though Terrance Dicks' novelisation is still an improvement on the broadcast original, particularly because the monsters are not visibly ludicrous.)

I revised upwards my opinion of three of the performances. First, Troughton is not just good, he is excellent, and rather steals the show from Pertwee. He gets a lot of the best lines - there is one about confusing the anti-matter blob by letting it watch television which must surely have been an ad-lib. Second, Courtney's Brigadier, if considered as an admittedly comedic authority figure, is actually pretty decent and he also gets some good nostalgia moments - thinking that Pertwee has changed back into Troughton and framing the situation as best he can. It's not the Brigadier of The Invasion or Spearhead from Space, but we haven't really had him around for a while. And third, the music is not half as bad as I remembered; I think it has to work hard to cover for the awful monsters, but does the job.

This time round I was watching the DVD, which includes a 1993 convention interview with Jon Pertwee and a 1973 Pebble Mill interview with Patrick Troughton - who looks very nervous and ill-at-ease, either he hadn't yet developed the convention-attending skills he later displayed until the day he died, or perhaps he just wasn't feeling well. There is also the 1973 Who retrospective from Blue Peter, starting with Pertwee (as himself) driving the Whomobile into the studio and then continuing with a potted history of the show, including Peter Purves introducing himself as Steven by showing Katarina's death scene from The Daleks' Master Plan - rather OTT for Blue Peter, I thought, but presumably we have Purves' choice of clip to thank for its survival when the rest of the episode was trashed.

My copy of the DVD itself has a rather special provenance. A few months ago I noticed that several items of Who memorabilia which had been sent to Verity Lambert as courtesy copies by BBC Enterprises were being auctioned on eBay (to raise funds for cancer research), and I ended up buying this DVD and (slightly by accident) a videotape of An Unearthly Child. The latter had been watched, but Lambert (who died in late 2007) had not opened the DVD, which she must surely have received, probably unsolicited, shortly after its release in 2003. On a couple of the First Doctor DVD commentaries, she remarks that she felt very sorry about Hartnell's increasingly poor health when they were working together; watching The Three Doctors, Hartnell's last acting role before his death, would hardly have made her feel better on that score, so I am not surprised that the plastic wrapper was still sealed when I got it.

Comments

( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
bookzombie
Aug. 29th, 2009 11:35 am (UTC)
The Three Doctors has a special place for me, mainly on the grounds that it is the first DW story that I definitely remembered seing in its entirety.

And yes, Patrick Troughton pretty much steals the show, the Brig is fun and poor Hartnell looks as if he died several weeks earlier and is just being propped up...
wshaffer
Aug. 29th, 2009 05:28 pm (UTC)
Coincidentally, I just picked this up on DVD - I don't think I've seen it since I was in my early teens, when I uncritically loved any story involving Time Lords because it offered a rare glimpse into the Doctor's back story. (Though I have more recently seen clips of the gel guard monsters, which made me laugh out loud - I can't remember if they did that when I was a teenager.) It'll be interesting to see what I think of it now.
padawanpooh
Aug. 30th, 2009 01:54 pm (UTC)
The Three Doctors has always been my favourite Classic story (and is probably my favourite over any New Who story too). The bickering between Two and Three, the Jo/Three ship moments and the fabulous Benton win for me every time :-) I'm glad you enjoyed it more on a rewatch.
scarfman
Aug. 30th, 2009 04:20 pm (UTC)

I won't dispute that Troughton was the best performer in The Three Doctors, but I still maintain that The Two Doctors was the only reunion story in which he wasn't written (and/or directed) as a caricature of the character he played when he was the lead.

iblis_kukl
Aug. 30th, 2009 07:17 pm (UTC)
I just looked at this one again last week.

Both the Gell monsters and the Ergon look just a bit less dire in the still photos in Justin Richards' Aliens and Enemies guide than on the video. That said, the cyclopean eye that each of the Gell monsters is sporting is actually kinda cool if you have a more careful look at them while they're lumbering around.

And I can never get enough of the expression on the Brig's face when he first sets eyes on Troughton again. Classic.


eliazar
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

March 2019
S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by yoksel