?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Writing McCain

One of the great things about Wikipedia is that it can be a sort of informal translation and transliteration service. I've been spending some happy if slightly pointless time looking at the ways in which different languages write John McCain's name, taken from the sidebar of his Wikipedia entry. There are no less than 66 different language versions of the article on him (some very brief). 43 of those are in variations of the Latin alphabet, and 42 of those 43 use McCain's own spelling of his name. The one exception is Azeri, where the letter "c" is pronounced like English "j", so not surprsinigly "McCain" becomes "Makkeyn"; by way of compensation, "John" becomes "John".

There are seven Cyrillic alphabet entries for McCain. Russian, Ukrainian and Bulgarian have united around Джон Маккейн ("Džon Makkeyn") which is reasonably phonetic. Both versions of Belarusian drop a к and have Джон Макейн. Serbian actually has a letter for the English 'J' sound, but lacks the й letter, so there we have Џон Макејн. (There isn't a Macedonian entry, but if there were it would have that spelling too.) The last Cyrillic entry is not a Slavic language, but Mongolian: Жон МакКэйн - in Mongolian, the letter Жж is pronounced like English "Ch" as in "church", and they don't have a "J" sound. I think this is the only non-Latin spelling where there is a capital letter in the middle of McCain's surname.

Hebrew and Yiddish display another problem for the transliterator: do you try and capture the unwritten vowel in the first syllable of "McCain"? Of course, it comes from the Irish "Mac", so (as the Cyrillic transcriptions do) you can write it with a vowel (as in Yiddish,דזשאן מעקעין); or you can reflect the fact that most English speakers more or less omit the vowel (as in Hebrew, ג'ון מקיין).

There's a similar contrast between Arabic and Farsi - Arabic goes for including the first vowel in McCain - جون ماكي - but Farsi prefers instead to double the letter "ک" (as Russian, Ukrainian and Bulgarian double the "к") - جان مک‌کی - unfortunately there doesn't seem to be a handy Urdu transliteration which would break the tie.

In Chinese, there's no question of doubling consonants, but as far as I can tell the Mandarin 約翰·麥凱恩 and Cantonese 麥凱恩 would have you pronounce the first vowel, while the Wu version, 马凱恩, rather mutes it. (Slightly puzzled that Cantonese and Wu just seem to use his surname.)

Going back to scripts I can actually read, the Georgian ჯონ მაკ-კეინი innovates by adding an extra vowel to the end - "jon mik-keini". Greek is fairly standard Τζον Μακέιν - "τζ" is normally pronounced "dz" in modern Greek, but is also the standard transliteration of the "j" sound.

The other transliterations, just for completeness, are Bengali/Bishnupriya Manipuri জন ম্যাককেইন; Marathi जॉन मॅककेन; Tamil ஜான் மெக்கெய்ன; Korean 존 매케인; Thai จอห์น แมคเคน and Japanese ジョン・マケイン.

Because Obama's name is much more easy to spell in any language, the transliteration questions are not as interesting (assuming you found them at all interesting in the first place). It is striking that while there are 66 Wikipedia articles on McCain there are 91 on Obama. This inevitably means a few new alphabets:

ባራክ ኦባማ (Amharic, which is the main language of Ethiopia)
(Dhivehi, the main language of the Maldives) ބަރާކް އޮބާމާ
बराक ओबामा (Hindi)
ಬರಾಕ್ ಒಬಾಮ (Cambodian)
ബറാക്ക് ഒബാമ (Malayalam)

There now, aren't you glad you know that!

Tags:

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
jdigital
Oct. 5th, 2008 05:42 am (UTC)
Interesting!
burkesworks
Oct. 5th, 2008 07:49 am (UTC)
Let's not forget Albanian, where non-Albanian names are usually rendered phonetically; he'd be known as Xhon Mekein in that country.
nwhyte
Oct. 5th, 2008 09:21 am (UTC)
Absolutely. No doubt the Albanian Wikipedians will reflect that in due course!
inuitmonster
Oct. 5th, 2008 11:21 am (UTC)
I remember hearing a story about someone who visited Albania during the years of its communist isolation. While in a school they noticed that someone had scratched "Mikal Jaxon" on their desk, suggesting that the country was less than totally isolated.
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

March 2019
S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by yoksel