?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Logopolis, Kinda, Snakedance

Those of you who care will have noticed that I'm working my way through classic Who in vaguely historical order; so since I finished the first three Doctors last year, I've been gradually ticking off the Tom Baker stories. The result of this has been that I am now least well versed in the Davison era, so I have been compensating a bit - Logopolis, Tom Baker's last story, ends with Davison's first though wordless appearance in the role, and Kinda and Snakedance are an interesting pairing, featuring the only returning monster of the Davison era (guest appearances in The Five Doctors aside). Also, all three stories are, in a deep sense, weird, trying to fit a lot more intellectual concepts into the Who format that usual, with varying degrees of success.

I saw Logopolis (of course) back in 1981 and again when it was repeated later in the year. Its biggest problem is that the pacing doesn't quite match the amount of Stuff that is Happening; the first episode in particular is alarmingly slow, episode two is incomprehensible in places, and it is not surprising that the ratings for the last two episodes were so low.

But the two million viewers who gave up on it between eps 2 and 3 were mistaken. Things I liked about it: the Watcher works really well, even though we never really find out the details of how he works. It generally looks fascinating - the nested Tardises, the streets of Logopolis. John Fraser as the Monitor is great. Nothing that the Master does actually makes sense, but it's a great debut story for Ainley who does some high-class evil laughter. Nyssa may pop out of nowhere but it's good to have her back (and out-acting Adric almost instantly). The music is super - the theme for the Watcher suggesting that he is not the Master (as Adric assumes) but something else, and that final chord sequence as it transforms into the Doctor Who theme.

The biggest problem I have with it now is that the Master's grand plan simply doesn't compute. How can he have known that the Doctor was headed for the Barnet by-pass? Or would then head for Logopolis? And how quickly will his message to the peoples of the universe reach them, indeed how will the radio telescope, sending messages at sluggish old light-speed, be able to affect the CVE in time? (And since Logopolis is out of commission, who will do this in future next time there is an entropy crisis?) We'll leave out the fact that the Third Doctor survived a much longer fall in The Paradise of Death, since that story is of dubious canonicity.

Logopolis is not one of the great regeneration stories - there are four of those, and they are The Tenth Planet, The War Games, The Caves of Androzani and Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways. But it is no way as bad as either Planet of the Spiders or (stretching a point as there is no regeneration) The Ultimate Foe. Good watching, with emphasis on watching rather than trying to understand what is going on.

The DVD is almost worth the cover price alone for the documentary on the transition between Doctors, "A New Body At Last", featuring interviews with Davison, Baker (as hilarious as ever) and numerous other cast and crew.

I also saw Kinda on first showing in 1982, and in some ways it is even less comprehensible than Logopolis, though in other ways it is fairly clear what is going on - giant pink snake trying to penetrate Tegan's inner recesses, and all that. It is one of Doctor Who's most successful takes on colonialism (a theme the Pertwee era consistently tried and failed with) even though that isn't really the point of the story. Wood and Miles point to the influence of Ursula Le Guin's The Word for World is Forest, and while I can see that, I think it may be a more general reflection of the ecological concerns of the day. The deep themes are laid on pretty heavily - the apple in paradise, the reflections of the "real" world in Tegan's dream, and on the whole we are shown rather than told about it. There are some impressive performances - Janet Fielding as Tegan of course, the three colonial officers (though we never find out what happened to their missing colleagues) the two Kinda women and the Trickster, which means you can almost overlook the cheapness of the sets and how wooden Adric is. Rather fascinating.

Unlike the other two stories here, I missed Snakedance first time round in 1983. It is actually good, perhaps the best Fifth Doctor story apart from The Caves of Androzani. There are two things that really make it so. First, the setting is completely convincing - this really does seem like a planet whose society extends beyond the edge of the camera's point of view. Not having the same constraints as the TV stories, the Big Finish audios have usually been much more successful at doing this, and Snakedance is a rare hit in this regard (especially for this era). The second strike in favour is the cast: Adric has been disposed of, and the irritating (and ultimately evil) young man of this story is none other than Martin Clunes, later of course one of the Men Behaving Badly. But it's unfair to the others to single him out; everyone is pretty good (again, special mention for Janet Fielding). The plot is a lot more comprehensible too, if anything almost too much like a standard Who plot, with the notable exception that rather than everyone suddenly agreeing to accept the leadership of the Doctor, who has just appeared out of nowhere, to get them through the crisis, they sensibly try and get on with it themselves and regard him as a nuisance. All very watchable.

Comments

( 12 comments — Leave a comment )
qatsi
Feb. 23rd, 2008 12:20 pm (UTC)
How can he have known that the Doctor was headed for the Barnet by-pass?

I can imagine some hand-waving explanation that the Doctor had mentioned it while on Traken, in conversation with Tremas, and the Master had assimilated the knowledge.

Although it's quite rarified, Logopolis is one of my favourite stories. I disagree with you slightly about great regeneration stories - I would count Logopolis as one of those and I'd drop The Caves of Androzani. But maybe that's because Logopolis was the first regeneration story I saw, and the other ushered in a new low point in the classic series.
inuitmonster
Feb. 23rd, 2008 01:50 pm (UTC)
I've seen the last two Tom Baker stories and the first three episodes of Castrovalva recently. I was struck by how annoying Tegan is... she is rubbish and incompetent yet spends all her time whining. I liked Adric a lot more than everyone else does, he seems strange rather than wooden, like a lot of those mathematician types.
nwhyte
Feb. 23rd, 2008 07:33 pm (UTC)
Yeah, part of the reason I watched Kinda and Snakedance is that they are the only two stories in which she gets to do something else!

seawasp is also an Adric defender.
blue_condition
Feb. 23rd, 2008 08:14 pm (UTC)
I found it very easy to dislike some aspects of the show during the "Lots of people in the Tardis bickering" years - which I think really damaged the Fifth Doctor era. We just didn't see enough of him. I much prefer the RTD "floating ensemble with companions semi-attached to their original timeline" approach, as long as it doesn't get too soapy.
inuitmonster
Feb. 26th, 2008 09:00 pm (UTC)
although a problem of this kind of RTD thing is you end up not actually doing very much travelling in time and space.
bookzombie
Feb. 23rd, 2008 02:31 pm (UTC)
Um, I assume when you say "featuring the only returning monster of the Davison era" you mean the only monster that was a Davison-era creation? Otherwise we have Daleks, Cybermen, Omega, Sea-Devils, Mutants, the Black Guardian (off the top of my head).
nwhyte
Feb. 23rd, 2008 07:34 pm (UTC)
Mutants?

I meant the only creatures to appear twice in the Davison era, apart from the guest spots for Daleks and Cybermen in The Five Doctors. I don't count the Master and the Black Guardian as they are villains rather than monsters!
bookzombie
Feb. 23rd, 2008 10:21 pm (UTC)
Not sure where the mutants came from...
mscongeniality
Feb. 23rd, 2008 03:42 pm (UTC)
We'll leave out the fact that the Third Doctor survived a much longer fall in The Paradise of Death, since that story is of dubious canonicity.

My feeling on that relatively short fall triggering a regeneration was that for some reason, his time was past. He knew it ever since the Watcher first showed up, and the longer he went on in the Watcher's presence, any misstep could trigger the regeneration.

I could also be over-rationalizing.
nwhyte
Feb. 23rd, 2008 07:35 pm (UTC)
My problem with that is that it is a slightly circular argument; the Watcher is generated, in a sense, by the regeneration, so we stuill have the same problem!
blue_condition
Feb. 23rd, 2008 08:12 pm (UTC)
Logopolis didn't work for me first time round, because IT TOOK TOM BAKER AWAY! - but on subsequent viewing, cheesy effects apart (the Watcher included), the conceptual depth of the story was excellent - and I liked the way the themes of recursion and mathematics continued into Castrovalva.
box_in_the_box
Feb. 23rd, 2008 09:35 pm (UTC)
Kinda works more for what it alludes to than what's actually on the screen, although what was on the screen was compelling enough to unnerve me a great deal as a child.

I never hid behind the couch from any of the monsters in the original series - even as a little boy, they were too obviously Aliens From The Planet Of Aluminum Foil And Papier-Mache for me to be anything other than amused by them - but seeing Janet Fielding do her best impression of Linda Blair in The Exorcist freaked me the holy hell out of me, because it betrayed the sacrosanct covenant of '80s kids' TV, which was that the "good guys" should remain recognizably a) good and b) friends throughout (Tom Baker's performance in The Invasion of Time was similarly unsettling to me, for those same reasons).

Moreover, Simon Rouse as Hindle was one of the few original series villains who truly scared me, because he was a grown man, with all the power over the world around him that implied, acting out with all of the temper-tantrums arbitrary petulance of a small child, and as a small child myself, who was self-aware enough about my own age to recognize how bad that could get, that was a genuinely terrifying notion.

As an adult, I can look back on Kinda and be fascinated by its use of cycles; the "end of everything" hallucinatory vision sequence was obvious enough to me as a kid, but the trinities of the tribe (Karuna the maiden, Todd the mother, and Panna the crone) and the colony (Adric the son, Hindle the father and Sanders the grandfather) were not at all apparent to me back then, even though they're glaringly visible in retrospect.

Also, Nerys Hughes as Todd had a wonderful chemistry-of-equals with Peter Davison's Doctor, which is something both the original and current series could use a lot more of (for all their occasional snarkiness toward each other, the Third Doctor clearly regarded Liz Shaw as a peer), rather than the all-too-common Pygmalion-gone-wrong dynamic (Louise Jameson as Leela made it work, but only because she had a non-Mary Sue reason to be an ass-kicker), and I can think of few other Doctors besides Davison who could have fit so well into the explicitly spelled-out "fool's journey" that the Doctor goes on here.
( 12 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

May 2019
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by yoksel